Tories in bid to protect Redbridge green belt accidentally vote through Labour amendment

PUBLISHED: 15:30 27 March 2019

Keith Prince met with residents at the site. Photo: Raymond Small

Keith Prince met with residents at the site. Photo: Raymond Small


Redbridge’s Conservative group was left red-faced after accidentally voting through a Labour amendment to their bid to protect the borough’s green belt from development.

A resident campaigns against the markets coming to Redbridge. Photo: Chris Gannaway,A resident campaigns against the markets coming to Redbridge. Photo: Chris Gannaway,

Group leader Cllr Linda Huggett put forward a motion calling for the local authority to “keep the existing green belt boundaries, as set out in the Redbridge Local Plan 2015/30 until 2030” at the full council meeting in Redbridge Town Hall on Thursday, March 21.

But Labour Cllr Sheila Bain, cabinet member for planning and planning enforcement, tabled a caveat to the motion allowing development on the green belt if “exceptional circumstances arise, or very special circumstances can be evidenced”.

A vote on this amendment was backed by all 45 Labour members in attendance, with the 12-strong Conservative group voting against.

Councillors then had a lengthy debate on the Tories’ now-amended motion before holding a second “substantive” vote.

Opposition councillors cheered as the live voter display turned green – indicating the motion had unanimous support.

But the elation was quickly replaced with confusion over whether they were voting on their original motion or the amended one.

“It was on the substantive motion as amended,” Mayor Debbie Kaur-Thiara clarified.

Cllr Huggett said: “If that was the vote, then I would like to take the vote again.”

Cllr Kaur-Thiara simply responded: “No.”

This debate came as more than 1,800 people have signed a petition to prevent the proposed relocation of three iconic London markets to green belt land on Fairlop Plain.

Councillor Howard Berlin (Con, Fairlop) told the chamber that the protection of the green belt historically had “cross party support” across Labour and Conservative governments.

“We should be protecting our green belt,” he said.

“One of [council leader Jas Athwal’s] legacies could be the destruction of the Redbridge green belt.”

Cllr Berlin highlighted that he had written two reviews of the Redbridge green belt and insisted that the Labour administration is going against government policy.

“It is disappointing that Cllr Berlin cannot agree with the wording,” Cllr Athwal responded.

“The wording comes straight from the national planning policy framework.”

If you value what this story gives you, please consider supporting the Ilford Recorder. Click the link in the orange box below for details.

Become a supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years, through good times and bad, serving as your advocate and trusted source of local information. Our industry is facing testing times, which is why I’m asking for your support. Every single contribution will help us continue to produce award-winning local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Thank you.

Most Read

Most Read

Latest from the Ilford Recorder