Goodmayes mental health patient killed by train should not have been released, jury decides

PUBLISHED: 13:15 28 June 2017 | UPDATED: 14:50 28 June 2017

The inquest took place at Waltham Coroners Court.

The inquest took place at Waltham Coroners Court.


A Goodmayes mental health patient killed by a train a day after leaving hospital should not have been released, an inquest has concluded.

Christine Mary Smith, of Bushwood, Wanstead, took her own life at Stratford Underground Station at 7.03am on July 6 2016.

The 69-year-old grandmother - who had bipolar disorder and believed she was an MI5 agent - had consumed a significant amount of alcohol, had antipsychotic medication and anti-depressants in her system, and was carrying three packs of paracetamol.

Returning a unanimous conclusion of suicide at Waltham Coroners’ Court yesterday, the jury said North East London NHS Foundation Trust’s (NELFT) decision to grant Ms Smith seven days’ leave under a Section 17 order had contributed to her death.

They concluded: “The house was in an unsatisfactory condition and there should have been more of a progression with her leave.”

Sarah Deery, Ms Smith’s daughter who lives in Sweden, “had expressed shock at how quickly Mrs Smith was released from hospital”, the court heard.

There was a broken boiler and door awaiting repair although Ms Smith had been told that a carpenter would be fixing it the next day.

The house had already been professionally cleaned and Ms Smith had refused a live-in cleaner, according to her care community co-ordinator, Richard Kisembo.

Dr Babatunde Adeeko, who led the release at Goodmayes Hospital, in Barley Lane, Goodmayes, said Ms Smith had shown “no signs of resistance” about leaving and knew she could return to the ward at any point.

She was refused leave on May 23, after non-compliance with her anti-psychotic medication, but had been given mood-stabilising injections since.

Ms Smith denied having suicidal thoughts or thoughts of self-harm to NELFT’s Home Treatment Team (HTT) the day before her death.

Offering his condolences, A NELFT spokesman said the care plan was developed with Christine before her death and included preparing her home environment and 24-hour support while under the Section 17 leave.

He said: “In light of the efforts made to support Christine, her death was unexpected and all those involved in her care are very saddened by this tragic incident.”

You can call the Samaritans free from any phone on 116 123.

Related articles

Latest Ilford Stories


Gallagher, the proud title partner of Premiership Rugby, has launched a nationwide competition for community rugby clubs to win a training session coached by their local Gallagher Premiership Rugby club.


It’s official - a planning application to demolish the former Bodgers site has been received by Redbridge Council.


Essex club have performed well in previous games this term against teams near the top

Woodford Town will take their growing following to Walthamstow on Saturday eager to win two battles


Herons were without a game last Saturday owing to break in league fixtures


Romford director of football Alex Goldstone is hoping his new role as manager of Barkingside can be beneficial to both parties.

Neighbours left fuming after the council asked them to fork out £20,000 for planned repairs by 2023 could see their bills halved.

The O’s legend explained how he got involved in ‘The Greater Game’ and praised the club bringing out the commemorative kit


Are you an unpaid carer aged 25 or over? Are you interested in working towards getting into or back into work? Do you need practical help and support to get ready for this big step? If your answer is yes to at least two of these questions read on.

Struggling to find a buyer for your home in a slower market? We speak to Ilford property expert Nina Kaura from Portico about the Crossrail effect and why getting things right first time will get you the best price for your property.

Exchange Ilford is a shopping centre on a mission to make it a more welcoming and accessible place to the people of Redbridge.

Newsletter Sign Up

Ilford Recorder twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read news

Show Job Lists

Education Promo

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Ilford Recorder
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now