Surgeon tells third inquest into Barkingside woman’s death he stands by his actions

07:00 21 September 2016

Bernard Bloom with a picture of his sister Carmel Bloom. He has won a third inquest into the death of his sister who died in 2002 during a routine kidney stone operation.

Bernard Bloom with a picture of his sister Carmel Bloom. He has won a third inquest into the death of his sister who died in 2002 during a routine kidney stone operation.


A surgeon told the third inquest into the death of a Barkingside woman that he would not have changed his actions, despite her dying after a routine operation.

Carmel Bloom, 54, of Fremantle Road, was admitted to the privately-run BUPA Roding Hospital, Redbridge, now run by Spire Healthcare, on August 27, 2002, with severe pain.

After undergoing a kidney stone operation at the hospital – where she worked as a health controller – her condition deteriorated.

Like most private clinics, BUPA Roding did not have an emergency wing, so surgeon John Hines called 999 in the early hours of August 28 and Ms Bloom was rushed to Whipps Cross Hospital, Leytonstone.

She died 10 days later when her family switched off her life support machine.

Ms Bloom’s brother Bernard has campaigned tirelessly to secure the third inquest, citing fresh evidence that has come to light.

Yesterday, at the Royal Courts of Justice, central London, he asked Mr Hines if he would “act differently” in similar circumstances today.

“No,” the consultant urologist told senior coroner Karon Monaghan QC.

The Bloom family allege that the kidney stone operation was rushed, and that Miss Bloom was not monitored properly afterwards.

Mr Hines told the court he had assessed her three times in the early hours of the morning, and after finding fluid in her lungs reacted quickly.

“Had I not treated the pulmonary edema (fluid in the lungs) the patient could have died in the ward or in the ambulance,” he said.

“I was reacting to changes in a clinical situation, time goes faster than it seems.”

Anaesthetist Paul Timmis described how Ms Bloom was “talking and laughing” before the kidney stone operation.

This is the third time these consultants have given evidence about Ms Bloom’s death.

The first inquest in 2003 found she died of natural causes, but that verdict was quashed by the High Court a year later.

The second inquest in 2005 found lack of post-operative care contributed to her death.

That finding, deemed inadequate by the Bloom family, was also quashed.

The latest inquest resumes today.

Related articles

Latest Ilford News Stories

Views of Monkhams lane

Yellow lines and signs to combat a “danger road” will be completed shortly, said the council leader, after residents raised concerns that somebody could get killed.

Woodford Festival

If you walk around Woodford this weekend, expect to see music, dancing, poetry and theatre on every corner, as a nine-day festival gets underway.

Yesterday, 17:00
Police at the scene of August's shooting in Loxford Lane.

Residents have expressed concern over a lack of charges brought regarding a daylight shooting close to a park were children were playing.

Yesterday, 16:26
Kevin Wright's award winning picture titled 'Old Hall Salt Marshes. It was the overall winner at the Wanstead and Woodford Photographic Society's AGM.

A beautiful yet moody seascape shot at salt marshes in Essex has won a photography club’s annual competition.

Newsletter Sign Up

Most read news


Show Job Lists


Kit yourself out and go Apple mad!

If you’re obsessed with Apple or just love a good gadget, this is a prize that will blow you away! An incredible £3,333 to spend on Apple goodies! How would you like to be the proud new owner of the Apple Watch?

VW Golf Estate

As we grow older it becomes more and more important to have means to travel about safely and quickly. Our friendship groups and families grow and the need to have a car that is not only safe but also fast and big enough for all our needs is ever more important. There are many cars on the market for such needs but none deals with them as efficiently or as neatly as a VW Golf Estate. These cars are build strong, long lasting and spacious for a reason. They cater to the needs of many and are some of the most popular cars currently on the market.

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Ilford Recorder
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now