Nursery assistant convicted over death of Chigwell girl found hanging from playhouse

09:30 04 February 2013

Rhiya Malin, two, died after her head became lodged in a Wendy house

Rhiya Malin, two, died after her head became lodged in a Wendy house


A nursery assistant has been convicted of neglect over the death of a Chigwell toddler who became caught up in an outdoor playhouse and died from a heart attack.

Chelmsford Crown Court had been told the convicted assistant, Kayley Murphy, of Greenfields, Loughton, had been on her mobile four times in the half hour before the girl was discovered after staff had taken the rest of the group inside.

She was found guilty of failing to take responsibility for people at work and wept in the dock as the verdict was given on Friday.

Her co-accused, nursery manager Karen Jacobs, 38, of Mill Lane, High Ongar, was cleared of a similar charge.

Sentencing has now been adjourned until February 25 when Murphy will be sentenced along with the owners of the nursery, Casterbridge and Education and Casterbridge Day Nurseries. The companies have admitted a breach of health and safety rules.

The incident happened on November 7, 2007 in Eton Manor Day Nursery, Roding Lane, Chigwell, when little Rhiya Malin, two, of Chigwell, had been playing on a scooter and became trapped inside the playhouse.

Summing up the case judge Karen Walden-Smith said: “There was no evidence a checklist was carried out by Kayley Murphy but there is conflicting evidence whether the checklist was needed to be completed on every occasion.”

Each woman had pleaded not guilty to failing to take reasonable care for people “who may be affected by her acts or omissions at work”.

Neither gave evidence in their defence but Murphy had claimed she could supervise while on the phone.

Prosecutor Oliver Campbell had told the court: “A three wheel scooter was found and it is likely she [Rhiya] stood on it, it moved and she was trapped.”

Latest Ilford News Stories

Yesterday, 15:00
Redbridge Show.

A look back at the biggest story from this week 20, 40 and 60 years ago.

Yesterday, 12:00

A stunning new exhibition exploring Redbridge’s unique, 400-year relationship with western India, is set to thrill and intrigue residents for the next three months.

Yesterday, 10:00
Inspirational war effort posters used the eerie image of the zeppelin - known as 'the baby-killer' - to inspire young men to join the army

In this week’s heritage column, historian John Barfoot tells the story of Alfred de Bathe Brandon, who brought down a German zeppelin while based at Hainault in 1916.

Saturday, October 22, 2016
Izar Abdgalil-Bores who has been nominated for a Young Citizen Award by his Mum for cooking and helping the next door neighbour in the garden

He may only be 11 and a long way from entering the world of employment, but for one youngster it is never too early to start mapping out a career plan.

Newsletter Sign Up

Most read news


Show Job Lists


£3,000 goes a long way at Boots

Cosmetics, toiletries, vitamins and more. Boots is the number one choice when it comes to purchasing daily essentials.

Kit yourself out and go Apple mad!

If you’re obsessed with Apple or just love a good gadget, this is a prize that will blow you away! An incredible £3,333 to spend on Apple goodies! How would you like to be the proud new owner of the Apple Watch?

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Ilford Recorder
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now